Zcash Core Team Exodus Story, Crypto's Own OpenAI Drama
Original Author: The Rollup
Translation: Peggy, BlockBeats
Editor's Note: On January 8, Josh Swihart, CEO of Electric Coin Company (ECC), the core development team behind Zcash (ZEC), revealed that the ECC team had recently collectively left the original organizational structure and plans to establish a new company. The reason was that their superior governance entity Bootstrap (a nonprofit responsible for governing ECC and supporting Zcash) had experienced a "clear and sustained deviation" from Zcash's core mission in terms of governance direction.
The ECC believed that the existing nonprofit governance structure had severely constrained project expansion in terms of funding, incentives, and operational efficiency. Therefore, they chose to leave together and instead continue to advance Zcash-related products in a for-profit form. The nonprofit board Bootstrap in charge of governance, however, believed that this transition path could pose legal and political risks that were difficult to accept.
In the face of this disagreement, on January 9, former ECC CEO Josh Swihart announced the establishment of a new for-profit startup called CashZ (CashZ.org), with a focus on productizing and commercializing Zcash wallets, aiming to bring Zcash to its envisioned "billions of users" through a sustainable profit model.
After the news came out, the price of Zcash fell by about 20%, reflecting the market's high level of anxiety about the mass departure of the core development team.

Amidst this governance dispute, the crypto podcast The Rollup provided a representative industry perspective. Co-founders and hosts Andy and Robbie reviewed the entire process of the ECC team's departure and rapid establishment of CashZ in a live broadcast, believing that this was not a project collapse but a structural adjustment that was bound to happen sooner or later. In their view, the root cause of the conflict was not technical or visionary but rather the tension between organizational form and expansion goals: when a privacy protocol tries to move towards widespread adoption, the nonprofit governance structure often becomes the bottleneck.

Based on this assessment, Andy and Robbie are relatively optimistic about the establishment of CashZ. They believe that, without creating a new public chain, issuing a new token, but continuing to advance wallet products based on the existing Zcash codebase, a for-profit startup might actually provide a more realistic growth path for Zcash. This "departure" seems more like a restructuring around operational efficiency and scalability rather than an ecosystem split.
From a more macro perspective, Zcash's controversy once again highlights a recurring industry proposition: as cryptocurrency projects enter the "scalable implementation" stage, the conflict between non-profit foundations and for-profit teams is often no longer a battle of ideas but a trade-off between efficiency and risk control. Zcash may just be the latest example.
The following is the original text:
The Birth of CashZ and Team Departures
Andy: Yes, Josh just posted that tweet. Our position is clear: we are fully committed to Zcash. Zcash must scale to billions of users. A startup can achieve scale, but a non-profit organization cannot. That's why we founded the new startup company CashZ.

Rob: So they are actually building a brand-new wallet.
Andy: Yes, but based on the same Zcash codebase, with the project codenamed CashZ. If you are a Zcash user, you just need to join the waitlist.
Josh also mentioned in yesterday's tweet that in the past few weeks, the situation has become very clear: most of the Bootstrap board members responsible for managing ECC, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit organization—especially Zaki, Manny, Christina Garman, Allan Fairless, and Michelle Lai—have been called out. The situation itself has already been quite out of control.
Mission Misalignment and Constructive Discharge
Andy: He pointed out in the tweet that all of this stems from a clear misalignment with the core mission of Zcash. After being treated by ZCAM (an entity related to Zcash community governance) in a manner of 'constructive discharge,' the entire ECC team chose to resign collectively.
In essence, the terms of employment were unilaterally altered, making it impossible for us to fulfill our duties effectively and in line with professional ethics. We are indeed establishing a new company, but we are still the same team, with the same mission—to build an unstoppable privacy currency. It is important to emphasize that the Zcash protocol itself has not been affected.
Rob: He also included a link specifically explaining what 'constructive discharge' is. By definition, this refers to a situation where an employer creates a hostile or intolerable work environment, or through other forms of pressure and coercion, forces an employee to resign; in legal terms, such resignation may not be considered voluntary.
Andy: Yes, in response to this news, Zcash's price has clearly dropped by about 20%.
Community Response and Zaki Manian Controversy
Rob: Arthur has also started to be "sarcastic". No matter how it is embellished, this situation doesn't look good. Balaji has always emphasized: Zcash can scale, must scale, and will eventually scale.
And now, Zaki has clearly borne the brunt of the criticism. Some have even accused him of "plundering and sabotaging" the Cosmos ecosystem, and now messing up the Zcash team.
Andy: Oh my. Zaki has been in this industry for many years and has indeed done a lot of excellent work. At least on this point, I am willing to stand up to defend Zaki. To be honest, I am not clear about what exactly happened internally.
Game of Profit and Non-Profit (Analogous to OpenAI)
Andy: Zooko has stated that these individuals, including Zaki, Allan, and Christina, all have very high integrity standards. Obviously, there has been a fundamental misalignment in the ethical and moral understanding of Zcash's mission between the two sides.
Rob: This sounds almost like the divergence that occurred in OpenAI years ago: some believe that only a for-profit organization can truly achieve scalability and deliver value continuously; while others insist that a non-profit structure is the correct and more secure choice.
Andy: Zaki subsequently also issued a statement expressing regret for this outcome. From Bootstrap's perspective, the board did indeed discuss the possibility of introducing external investment and exploring the possibility of "privatization" through alternative structures, working closely with legal counsel throughout to ensure that any path complies with U.S. non-profit law.
However, it must be acknowledged that the institutional constraints faced by non-profit organizations are indeed real, and properly addressing these constraints in a constantly changing environment is extremely complex.
Rob: It sounds like Zaki was actually also advocating for the establishment of a startup.
Root Cause of the Final Disagreement
Andy: The opposition believes that in the current version, the proposed transaction scheme would introduce new vulnerabilities for politically motivated attacks against Zcash, and could even make any donor susceptible to litigation. Therefore, their core goal is to prevent the entire Zcash ecosystem from facing systemic risk. Some proposals initially made for the "greater good" have ultimately evolved into the catalyst for the split.
Rob: It is indeed regrettable because in the end, it turns out that the two sides' positions were not that far apart. Both sides wanted to transform the original non-profit structure into some form of for-profit entity in order to be able to continuously generate revenue, build, and expand Zcash. The reason they eventually parted ways was simply because they could never agree on "how to securely take this step."
You may also like

Make Probability an Asset: A Forward-Looking Perspective on Predictive Market Agents

Consumer application issues

Arthur Hayes: The flames of war in the Middle East rise, Bitcoin is bullish

Legendary investor Naval: In the AI era, traditional software engineers have no value?

More absurd than knowing about the war in advance is knowing in advance about the assassination of Soleimani

Key Market Insights on March 2nd, how much did you miss?

How to systematically track high-performing addresses on Polymarket?

From Stanford Lab to Silicon Valley Streets: How OpenMind is Solving the "Last Mile" Problem of the Machine Economy?

PlanX: Reconstructing On-Chain Execution with AI, Moving Towards a New Paradigm

US Judge Allows Binance Unregistered Token Lawsuit to Advance
Key Takeaways: A federal judge in Manhattan dismissed Binance’s petition to resolve a securities lawsuit through private arbitration,…

Crypto VC Paradigm Plans $1.5 Billion Expansion into AI and Robotics
Key Takeaways: Paradigm is setting up a new $1.5 billion fund to explore AI, robotics, and other emerging…

Ethereum Smart Accounts Set to Launch Within a Year, According to Vitalik Buterin
Key Takeaways: Ethereum’s “account abstraction” or smart accounts might be introduced in the coming year through the Hegota…

Bitcoin Recovers After Iran Conflict Shocks Market, Reverses $5K Fall in Just 24 Hours
Key Takeaways: Bitcoin dropped to approximately $63,000 amid tensions but rebounded to $68,200 within a day. Volatility led…

Former Mt. Gox CEO Suggests Hardfork to Retrieve $5.2 Billion in Bitcoin
Key Takeaways: Mark Karpelès, former CEO of Mt. Gox, proposes a Bitcoin network hard fork to access nearly…

South Korea National Tax Service’s Mistake Resulted in $4.8 Million Crypto Loss
Key Takeaways South Korea’s National Tax Service inadvertently exposed private keys, resulting in a $4.8 million crypto loss.…

Morgan Stanley Seeks National Trust Charter for Cryptocurrency Custody
Key Takeaways: Morgan Stanley has initiated a significant step toward digital asset management by applying for a national…

Solana Price Outlook: Major ETF Inflows Hint at Institutional Moves
Key Takeaways: Solana has experienced substantial ETF inflows, prompting speculation about institutional buy-in. On February 25, Solana recorded…

Bitcoin Price Prediction: Wikipedia Founder Warns BTC Could Plunge Below $10K — Should Investors Worry?
Key Takeaways Wikipedia co-founder Jimmy Wales warns Bitcoin might decline to below $10,000, prompting a bearish outlook. Wales…